Skip to content Skip to footer

Dental Hygiene Newswire

News and research for Ontario dental hygienists

Health effects of permanent standard time versus permanent daylight saving time

Key messages:

  • Several Canadian regions are weighing permanent standard time (ST) against permanent daylight saving time (DST) now that twice-yearly clock changes are being ended.
  • Ending clock changes removes the harms of the twice-yearly shift, but jurisdictions must still choose between permanent ST and permanent DST, which affect light exposure and health differently by season and location.
  • Permanent DST keeps evenings light, aiding commuting, recreation, social life, and some economic activity, but lengthens dark winter mornings, which may harm circadian alignment, sleep, mood, education, and productivity.
  • Permanent ST fits circadian biology better, though earlier dusk may limit some evening activities.
  • Health evidence and major sleep and chronobiology societies favour permanent ST. Any jurisdiction adopting permanent DST should plan mitigation, protect the most affected groups, and transparently monitor population health.

Introduction

Several Canadian regions are deciding between permanent standard time (ST) and permanent daylight saving time (DST) as they end twice-yearly clock changes. Seasonal changes bring long summer evenings and earlier winter light, but the spring “leap forward” harms health through sleep loss and short-term increases in illness and injury. Most recent reviews suggest ending clock changes would remove these transition harms, and major sleep and chronobiology societies urge abolishing them in favour of permanent ST. Still, North American jurisdictions that have ended time changes mostly chose permanent DST: Yukon in 2020, British Columbia in March 2026, and Alberta and the Northwest Territories a month later.

This analysis examines:

  • Public health implications of a permanent time standard across Canadian jurisdictions.
  • How human circadian biology may respond to permanent ST and permanent DST.
  • Effects of permanent ST or permanent DST on physical and mental health and broader determinants of health.
  • International experience with ending biannual time changes.
  • Ways to monitor and mitigate population health impacts of the policy change.

Conclusion

Time-standard decisions need a cross-sectoral, Health in All Policies approach that weighs health implications and coordinates government action to prevent harm and improve population health and equity. Ending biannual clock changes may remove transition harms lasting a few weeks, but the effects of a permanent time are likely chronic. Permanent ST may protect the winter morning light most vital to circadian rhythms, sleep, and mood, whereas permanent DST would worsen winter sleep and mental health, especially for youth, workers (among whom minorities are overrepresented), and people with sleep disorders. The weight of health evidence favours permanent ST, which aligns with recommendations of sleep and chronobiology societies worldwide and would help Canada avoid repeating other countries’ failed permanent DST experiments. Regions that choose permanent DST should reduce health impacts through advance mitigation, protection for vulnerable groups, and transparent evaluation.

Click here to read the article.

Show CommentsClose Comments

Leave a comment